What would the law say about converting Youtube videos to MP3

What would the law say about converting Youtube videos to MP3

In recent years, piracy has dropped considerably in Romania. If in the early 2000s, everyone had a torrent application, today we rarely meet a computer equipped with such a thing. People don't copy many movies or games anymore, but in terms of songs, some can hardly resist the temptation to convert a rare song to MP3. Is there a risk if we resort to this gesture? Let's explain the topic in more detail in the following paragraphs, to clarify when and how it is ok to download songs from the web.

Piracy has dropped considerably in terms of copying movies, games, applications and music in Romania. People have recognized the importance of buying original, licensed content. If in terms of movies and applications, things are almost as in civilized countries, in terms of music, many people still download MP3s, through browser plugins, directly from Youtube. Is this practice equal to piracy? See:

Is song conversion illegal?

To provide a timely and direct answer to this question, we announce that no, it is not at all illegal to convert a video file on YouTube into a format that allows its storage on your computer or other gadgets. You can easily install browser plugins that allow this process, none of which are illegal. Things get complicated when we discuss the copyright status of a video file and what to do if we copy it from the place where it was posted and publish it somewhere.

To give an example, let's say you came across a song that belongs to a famous artist, this being posted directly on the artist's YouTube channel. If you decide to download it and then use it to make money (for example, burn a CD with songs and sell it to other people), then the action is illegal, as you make a profit without paying the original artist the royalties. author insured by law.

What would the law say about converting Youtube videos to MP3

Another example is the following: let's say you bought an original CD with an artist's album. If you have a YouTube channel and turn a song from CD to MP3, then post it on your own channel, this is illegal, as you infringe copyright here as well. Things are even worse as you make money from that post, through ads.

We would also like to mention that some songs and albums may be in the public domain. We are talking about very old songs, which belong to artists who lived a long time ago, and no record company has acquired the rights to publish their music. In such cases, you can download and convert the respective songs without any problems.

To conclude, you can download songs from YouTube in MP3 for your own listening, because after all no one will enter your player or phone to check your playlist.

Is it worth converting songs today, since so many are present online?

Nowadays, given the ubiquitous high-speed wi-fi connections and the vastness of songs on YouTube, Spotify, Deezer or iTunes, the question already arises as to whether it's still worth bothering with converting them to MP3 for download. Why give so many clicks, after all, when we can just press Play?

To answer, we can show that there are people who do not want to stay connected non-stop to the Internet, or who want to avoid ads that appear from time to time on YouTube, between songs. A playlist stored in their player's memory is a suitable solution for the needs listed above. In addition, playlists of this type, with MP3 or FLAC files, are easier to organize. For example, you can sort the songs in a certain order, or you can sort them by artist, genre or album.

There is also the problem of financial support of the artist: if you care about this aspect, you can very well buy the album in digital or physical format on CD or vinyl, and then convert the songs to MP3 by listening to them on any gadget you want.

We also want to add that a song is worth converting, if it is something rare, that could disappear from the platform where it was posted.


Is it ok to post a song on Youtube on Facebook?

Given the various automatic algorithms that operate on Facebook, a song posted by you may be muted, meaning that it can no longer be listened to – the algorithm will automatically detect which song it is and, if it finds it on the list. music with which the social media platform will not let people listen to it. The same thing could happen on YouTube, if the algorithm detects certain songs.

This can be frustrating, but this way you won't find out about copyright issues. On the other hand, if the song is relatively obscure, it may not be included in the algorithm database, so you can post it without any problems.

Of course, from an ethical point of view, it would be good to pay for the song by buying that album. In addition, if you are a public, famous person, who makes money from posting a song, you will be more likely to be noticed by the artist, and please download the song, again invoking the rights of copyright.


Is there a risk of being sued by an artist?

The chances of this happening are quite small, and to offer a telling scenario, let's think that you have a YouTube channel, from which you make money, and in your videos you used a famous song.

Those videos may be muted if algorithms detect the song, and in some cases, even the original artist may ask you to download them. As expected, your refusal could lead to legal action by the artist.

We, of course, have provided a generic script here, and in practice, most often you may lose the sound on that song, or it may be dropped.

What would the law say about converting Youtube videos to MP3

But, according to the legislation that varies from platform to platform, it can be perfectly legal to use short pieces of a song, for 10, 20 or 30 seconds, for example. Such rules relate to use under the terms "fair use" – ie free use, under certain circumstances such as analysis, comments and the pamphlet.

Things could get more delicate when we talk about covers for some songs. For example, post a video with you singing out loud on the negative of a famous song. Automatic algorithms on that platform may not recognize the song, allowing it to remain posted.

Only the original artist, if he wishes, can take legal action against you, after first asking you to take him down. But, to be honest, such cases happen to be rare, if you do not have a well-known channel and if you do not make money from it.



In conclusion, it is perfectly legal to convert songs to listen to good MP3 players on both YouTube and other sites, if you only use them, do not give them to other people and do not make money from them. their. The rest of the issues discussed are related to the complicated field of copyright.

It is good to follow the artists you care about and follow some basic rules of business ethics. If all these instructions are followed, all you have to do is enjoy your favorite music without worries.

0 replies on “What would the law say about converting Youtube videos to MP3”